Skip to main content
Categories
Belief & Creed
General
Sunni & Shi’a
Resurrection & Afterlife
God & His Attributes
Prophethood & Imamate
Comparative Religion
Spirituality & Philosophy
General
Philosophy
Spirituality
Ethics
Quran & Hadith
General
Hadith Sciences
Hadith Collections
Qur’an Commentaries
Qur’anic Sciences
Education & Society
Family
Education
Women
Youth
General
Art, Images and Calligraphy
History & Politics
Prophet Muhammad
Ahl al-Bayt
Companions
Successors
Early Scholars
Sunni Scholars
Shia Scholars
Zaydi Scholars
Ismaili Scholars
Other Scholars
Politics & Current Affairs
Imam Ali
Fatima al-Zahra
Early Islamic History
General
Imam al-Husayn and Karbala
Imam al-Mahdi
Prophets
Laws & Worship
Death and Dying
Fasting
General
Hajj (Pilgrimage)
Zakat and Khums (Charity)
Islamic Laws
Hijab (Islamic Modest Dress)
Marriage
Salaat (Ritual Prayer)
Supplications
Miscellaneous
Toggle navigation
Search
Donate
Login
Flagellation
5 Questions
Why do some Shia engage in Zanjeer Zani? Is it considered a part of Shi'ism?
Sayyed Muhammad Husaini Ragheb
Could you provide me with proper references regarding permissibility of Matam? Additionally, which form of Matam is considered correct, simple Matam with hands or drawing blood through Zanjeerzani?
Sayyed Mohammad Al-Musawi
Why is Zanjeer considered forbidden but regular Matam is allowed when slapping yourself hard on your chest can also cause hurt? At what point or in what shape, if any, could Matam by hand be considered disallowed?
Sayyed Mohammad Al-Musawi
Sunnis often criticize the Shia for their methods of mourning, whether it be striking chests, cutting or self flagellation. How can we substantiate these actions?
Sayyed Mohammad Al-Musawi
Show More
Show more